Mistake Bank: Thermodynamics | Chemca

Home ❯ Mistake Bank ❯ Thermodynamics

The Mistake Bank

Chapter 6: Thermodynamics

Physics says one thing, Chemistry says another. Don't mix them up! From sign conventions to entropy units, master the rules of energy transfer.

1. The Sign Convention War

Work Done

Scenario: A gas expands from volume $V_1$ to $V_2$ against external pressure $P$. Is the work done positive or negative?

✖ What Students Do

Student uses the Physics formula:

$$ W = P \Delta V $$

Since volume increases ($\Delta V > 0$), they state work is Positive.

(In Chemistry, this guarantees a negative mark!)

✔ The Correct Way

Chemistry Focuses on the System!

When a gas expands, it does work ON the surroundings. Energy leaves the system, so the sign must be negative.

$$ W = - P_{ext} \Delta V $$

- Expansion: System loses energy $\rightarrow$ Work is Negative (-).
- Compression: System gains energy $\rightarrow$ Work is Positive (+).

2. The Entropy Unit Trap

Gibbs Energy

Scenario: Calculate $\Delta G$ if $\Delta H = -40 \text{ kJ/mol}$ and $\Delta S = -20 \text{ J/K·mol}$ at $300 \text{ K}$.

✖ What Students Do

Student plugs values directly into $\Delta G = \Delta H - T\Delta S$:

$$ \Delta G = -40 - (300 \times -20) $$

$$ \Delta G = -40 + 6000 = \mathbf{+5960} $$

(Disaster! You just mixed Kilojoules with Joules.)

✔ The Correct Way

Convert Units First!

$\Delta S$ is almost always given in Joules (J), while $\Delta H$ is usually in Kilojoules (kJ).

Convert $\Delta S$ to kJ:
$$ \Delta S = -20 \text{ J/K} = -0.020 \text{ kJ/K} $$ Now calculate $\Delta G$:
$$ \Delta G = -40 - (300)(-0.020) $$ $$ \Delta G = -40 + 6 = \mathbf{-34 \text{ kJ/mol}} $$

3. Isothermal vs. Adiabatic

Internal Energy

Scenario: An ideal gas expands adiabatically ($q=0$) against a constant external pressure. Does the temperature of the gas change?

✖ What Students Do

Student assumes "Expansion of ideal gas means constant temperature." They confuse this with Isothermal expansion.

Or, they think since $q=0$ (no heat exchange), the temperature cannot possibly change.

✔ The Correct Way

Work comes from Internal Energy!

According to the First Law: $\Delta U = q + w$. Since $q=0$, then $\Delta U = w$.

During expansion, the gas does work ($w$ is negative). Therefore, $\Delta U$ is negative.
Since internal energy of an ideal gas depends ONLY on temperature, a decrease in $\Delta U$ means a Drop in Temperature (Cooling).

4. The Vacuum Illusion (Free Expansion)

Work Done

Scenario: Calculate the work done when 2 moles of an ideal gas expands isothermally from 1L to 10L into a vacuum.

✖ What Students Do

Student sees "isothermally from 1L to 10L" and immediately grabs the reversible work formula:

$$ w = -2.303 nRT \log\left(\frac{V_2}{V_1}\right) $$

They spend 3 minutes calculating logs and submit a large numerical answer.

✔ The Correct Way

No Opposing Force = No Work!

"Into a vacuum" means it is a Free Expansion. The external pressure ($P_{ext}$) is exactly $0$.

$$ w = - P_{ext} \Delta V = 0 \times \Delta V = \mathbf{0} $$
Don't fall for the distracting numbers! For free expansion of an ideal gas: $w=0$, $q=0$, and $\Delta U=0$.

5. $\Delta H$ vs. $\Delta U$ Neglect

Thermochemistry

Scenario: For the Haber process: $N_2(g) + 3H_2(g) \rightarrow 2NH_3(g)$. Calculate the difference between Enthalpy change and Internal Energy change ($\Delta H - \Delta U$) at temperature T.

✖ What Students Do

Student forgets the relationship formula or assumes $\Delta H = \Delta U$ because they forgot to count the gaseous moles.

Result: They answer $0$.

✔ The Correct Way

Use $\Delta n_g RT$ !

$$ \Delta H = \Delta U + \Delta n_g RT $$

$\Delta n_g = (\text{moles of gaseous products}) - (\text{moles of gaseous reactants})$
$\Delta n_g = 2 - (1 + 3) = -2$

Therefore, $\Delta H - \Delta U = \Delta n_g RT = \mathbf{-2RT}$.

6. Spontaneity Criteria

Second Law

Scenario: "For a process to be strictly spontaneous, what specific thermodynamic property must always increase?"

✖ What Students Do

Student answers: "Entropy of the system ($\Delta S_{sys}$) must be positive."

(Wrong! Systems can become ordered spontaneously, e.g., water freezing into solid ice below 0°C, where $\Delta S_{sys}$ is negative.)

✔ The Correct Way

Total Entropy of the Universe must increase!

$$ \Delta S_{total} = \Delta S_{sys} + \Delta S_{surr} > 0 $$

Even if the system's entropy decreases (like freezing water), it releases heat into the surroundings ($\Delta H_{sys}$ is negative). This heat massively increases the entropy of the surroundings ($\Delta S_{surr}$), making the TOTAL entropy positive. Alternatively, use Gibbs Free Energy: $\mathbf{\Delta G_{sys} < 0}$.

7. The Bomb Calorimeter Trap

Calorimetry

Scenario: A student burns methane in a Bomb Calorimeter and measures the heat released as $-890 \text{ kJ/mol}$. They write $\Delta H_c = -890 \text{ kJ/mol}$. Is this correct?

✖ What Students Do

Student assumes any heat measured in any calorimeter is automatically the Enthalpy of reaction ($\Delta H$).

✔ The Correct Way

Bomb Calorimeters measure Internal Energy ($\Delta U$)!

A Bomb Calorimeter is a rigid, sealed steel container. This means the volume is strictly constant ($\Delta V = 0$).
If $\Delta V = 0$, then work $w = 0$.
From First Law: $q_v = \Delta U$.
The value measured is $\mathbf{\Delta U = -890 \text{ kJ/mol}}$. You must use $\Delta H = \Delta U + \Delta n_g RT$ to find Enthalpy!

8. The State Function Illusion

Basic Definitions

Scenario: True or False: "Because Heat ($q$) and Work ($w$) are both path functions, their sum ($q + w$) must also be a path function."

✖ What Students Do

Student applies basic logic: "Path function + Path function = Path function."

They confidently answer True.

✔ The Correct Way

FALSE! The sum is Internal Energy!

According to the First Law of Thermodynamics:
$$ \Delta U = q + w $$
Internal Energy ($\Delta U$) depends ONLY on the initial and final states of the system, regardless of how the change occurred. Therefore, $q + w$ is a State Function.

9. Standard State Blindspot

Enthalpy of Formation

Scenario: What is the standard enthalpy of formation ($\Delta H_f^\circ$) for Iodine gas, $I_2(g)$?

✖ What Students Do

Student remembers: "The enthalpy of formation of an element in its standard state is zero."

They see $I_2$, an element, and write: $\Delta H_f^\circ = \mathbf{0}$.

✔ The Correct Way

Check the physical state! Iodine is a SOLID at standard conditions.

Standard conditions implies 298K (25°C) and 1 bar pressure. At this temperature:
- $F_2$ and $Cl_2$ are gases.
- $Br_2$ is a liquid ($\Delta H_f^\circ = 0$ only for $Br_2(l)$).
- $I_2$ is a solid ($\Delta H_f^\circ = 0$ only for $I_2(s)$).
Therefore, $I_2(g)$ requires energy (sublimation) to form, so its $\Delta H_f^\circ$ is positive (non-zero).

10. The Weak Acid Exception

Enthalpy of Neutralization

Scenario: The heat of neutralization of strong acid + strong base is roughly $-57.1 \text{ kJ/mol}$. What is the heat of neutralization of Acetic Acid ($CH_3COOH$) with $NaOH$?

✖ What Students Do

Student assumes all neutralizations release the same amount of heat, since it's just $H^+ + OH^- \rightarrow H_2O$.

They guess $-57.1 \text{ kJ/mol}$.

✔ The Correct Way

Weak acids require energy to dissociate!

Unlike strong acids (which are 100% ionized), weak acids like $CH_3COOH$ are mostly unionized in solution.
A portion of the $-57.1 \text{ kJ}$ heat released is used up to break the O-H bond and fully dissociate the weak acid.
Therefore, the net heat released is less (e.g., around $-55.2 \text{ kJ/mol}$). (Note: HF is an exception that is *more* negative due to high hydration energy).

11. Work Area Deception

Work & Expansion

Scenario: An ideal gas expands from $V_1$ to $V_2$ isothermally. Which process does more work: Reversible or Irreversible expansion?

✖ What Students Do

Student thinks "Irreversible" sounds explosive and fast, so it must do more work.

✔ The Correct Way

Reversible expansion does Maximum Work!

On a P-V graph, work done is the area under the curve.
- Irreversible: Expansion against a suddenly lowered, constant external pressure (forms a rectangle under the curve).
- Reversible: Expansion where external pressure is infinitesimally smaller than internal gas pressure at all times. The curve is a smooth hyperbola, capturing the maximum possible area.
Magnitude: $|w_{rev}| > |w_{irrev}|$

12. Hess's Law Reversal Forgetfulness

Thermochemistry

Scenario: Given $A \rightarrow B$ has $\Delta H = -100 \text{ kJ}$. You need the reaction $2B \rightarrow 2A$ to solve a Hess's Law puzzle. What is its $\Delta H$?

✖ What Students Do

Student multiplies by 2 to get $-200 \text{ kJ}$, but completely forgets to account for the reversal of the reaction direction.

✔ The Correct Way

If you flip the reaction, you MUST flip the sign!

1. Reversing the reaction ($B \rightarrow A$) changes the sign: $\Delta H = +100 \text{ kJ}$.
2. Multiplying by 2 ($2B \rightarrow 2A$) scales the magnitude: $\Delta H = +100 \times 2 = \mathbf{+200 \text{ kJ}}$.
Don't rush the steps in Hess's Law calculations!

13. The Ideal Mixing Myth

Entropy

Scenario: Two non-reacting ideal gases, A and B, are mixed at constant temperature and pressure. What is the entropy change of mixing ($\Delta S_{mix}$)?

✖ What Students Do

Student thinks: "Ideal gases have no interactions. Therefore, mixing them doesn't require or release heat. If nothing happens, $\Delta S$ must be zero."

✔ The Correct Way

Mixing always increases randomness!

While it's true that for ideal gases $\Delta H_{mix} = 0$ (no heat exchange), entropy is a measure of microstates and disorder.
When two gases mix, they each expand to fill the entire total volume. The number of possible arrangements for the molecules increases massively.
Therefore, $\mathbf{\Delta S_{mix} > 0}$ (it is always positive for mixing).

14. Molar Properties Trap

Extensive vs Intensive

Scenario: Heat capacity ($C$) is an extensive property. Is Molar Heat Capacity ($C_m$) also extensive?

✖ What Students Do

Student assumes any type of heat capacity depends on the amount of substance, classifying it as Extensive.

✔ The Correct Way

"Molar" or "Specific" makes it Intensive!

- Heat Capacity ($C$): Depends on total mass (Extensive). A swimming pool has higher $C$ than a cup of water.
- Molar Heat Capacity ($C_m$): This is the heat capacity per ONE mole. Because the amount is fixed to one mole, it no longer depends on the total mass of your sample.
It is an Intensive property!

15. The Perfect Crystal Exception

Third Law

Scenario: According to the Third Law, entropy is zero at 0 K for a perfectly crystalline substance. What is the entropy of Carbon Monoxide (CO) crystals at 0 K?

✖ What Students Do

Student blindly applies the law and states $\Delta S = \mathbf{0}$.

✔ The Correct Way

Beware of Residual Entropy!

CO is a classic exception. Because the size of C and O atoms are so similar, CO molecules can crystallize in two orientations (CO or OC) with almost identical energies.
Even at absolute zero, there is randomness frozen into the crystal lattice because of these mixed orientations.
Therefore, it is not a "perfect" crystal, and its entropy at 0 K is greater than zero ($S > 0$).

Confess Your Sins!

"Thermodynamics is a funny subject. The first time you go through it, you don't understand it at all." - Arnold Sommerfeld

Did one of these catch you? Or do you have a different horror story from your last exam?

Scroll down to the comments section below and tell us:

"Which thermodynamic trap were you falling for?"

↓

Quiz Revision Notes Downloads Class Notes Video Lectures