Mistake Bank: Redox Reactions | Chemca

Home ❯ Mistake Bank ❯ Redox Reactions

The Mistake Bank

Chapter 8: Redox Reactions

Electron lost is electron gained... unless you miscalculate. From n-factors to electrochemical signs, bypass the traps that pull down your scores.

1. The Butterfly Structure Trap

Oxidation Number

Scenario: Calculate the oxidation number of Chromium in $CrO_5$ (Blue Perchromate).

✖ What Students Do

Student assumes normal oxide ($O^{2-}$) for all oxygens:

$$ x + 5(-2) = 0 \Rightarrow x = +10 $$

(Impossible! Max valence electrons of Cr is 6. You cannot lose what you do not have.)

✔ The Correct Way

Look for the Peroxide Linkage!

$CrO_5$ has a unique "butterfly" structure containing two peroxide bonds.

• 4 Peroxide Oxygens: Oxidation state is $-1$ each.
• 1 Normal Oxide Oxygen: Oxidation state is $-2$.

$$ x + 4(-1) + 1(-2) = 0 $$ $$ x - 4 - 2 = 0 \Rightarrow \mathbf{x = +6} $$

2. Standard Reduction Potential

Electrochemical Series

Scenario: Given $E^\circ(Li^+/Li) = -3.05V$ and $E^\circ(Ag^+/Ag) = +0.80V$. Which is the stronger Reducing Agent?

✖ What Students Do

Student thinks "Positive is better" or "Higher value means stronger".

Answer given: Silver ($Ag$).

(Incorrect! They confused Reducing Agent with oxidizing capability.)

✔ The Correct Way

More Negative = Stronger Reducing Agent!

A highly negative Standard Reduction Potential means the element hates being reduced (gaining electrons) and loves to oxidize (lose electrons).

Since it loves to oxidize itself, it easily reduces others. Lithium ($Li$) loses electrons most easily.
Answer: $\mathbf{Li}$ is the strongest Reducing Agent.

3. Balancing in Basic Medium

Balancing Redox

Scenario: Balance the half-reaction $MnO_4^- \rightarrow MnO_2$ in Basic medium.

✖ What Students Do

Student adds $H^+$ to balance Hydrogens and leaves it there.

$$ MnO_4^- + 4H^+ + 3e^- \rightarrow MnO_2 + 2H_2O $$

(Fatal Error: Free $H^+$ ions cannot exist in a Basic medium!)

✔ The Correct Way

Neutralize the $H^+$ with $OH^-$!

Add an equal number of $OH^-$ ions to both sides of the equation to cancel out the $H^+$.
Combine $4H^+ + 4OH^-$ to form $4H_2O$ on the left side.
$MnO_4^- + 4H_2O + 3e^- \rightarrow MnO_2 + 2H_2O + 4OH^-$

Cancel redundant water molecules:
$\mathbf{MnO_4^- + 2H_2O + 3e^- \rightarrow MnO_2 + 4OH^-}$

4. KMnO4 n-Factor Fluctuations

Titration

Scenario: Find the Equivalent weight of $KMnO_4$ in Neutral or Faintly Alkaline medium.

✖ What Students Do

Student memorizes that $KMnO_4$ undergoes a 5 electron change because that's the most common lab titration (Acidic medium).

$$ Eq. Wt = M / 5 $$

(Wrong! The medium changes the reduction product.)

✔ The Correct Way

Remember the "BAN 153" Rule!

Potassium Permanganate ($Mn^{+7}$) reduces differently depending on pH:

• Basic (Strongly): $Mn^{+7} \to Mn^{+6}$ (Change, $\mathbf{n=1}$)
• Acidic: $Mn^{+7} \to Mn^{+2}$ (Change, $\mathbf{n=5}$)
• Neutral/Faint Alkaline: $Mn^{+7} \to Mn^{+4}$ (Change, $\mathbf{n=3}$)

Correct Equivalent Weight: $\mathbf{M/3}$

5. The Fractional Oxidation State

Structure

Scenario: Calculate the oxidation state of Sulfur in the Tetrathionate ion ($S_4O_6^{2-}$).

✖ What Students Do

Student calculates using standard algebraic method:

$$ 4x + 6(-2) = -2 \Rightarrow 4x = 10 \Rightarrow x = +2.5 $$

Student thinks every sulfur atom possesses a non-integer +2.5 charge.

✔ The Correct Way

Fractional states are Average states! Look at the structure.

An individual atom cannot lose or gain half an electron. The structure $O_3S-S-S-SO_3$ reveals distinct environments:

• Two Central Sulfurs: Bonded only to other sulfur atoms (S-S). Their oxidation state is 0.
• Two Terminal Sulfurs: Bonded to three oxygens each. Their oxidation state is +5.

Average = $(5 + 0 + 0 + 5) / 4 = \mathbf{+2.5}$

6. Disproportionation vs Comproportionation

Types of Redox

Scenario: Identify the specific type of redox reaction: $NH_4NO_3 \xrightarrow{\Delta} N_2O + 2H_2O$

✖ What Students Do

Student sees Nitrogen in the reactant going to Nitrogen in the product.

Calls it "Disproportionation" because they remember it's a special type of single-element reaction.

✔ The Correct Way

Check the reactant states! It's Comproportionation.

In $NH_4NO_3$, Nitrogen exists in two different oxidation states:
- In the Ammonium ion ($NH_4^+$), N is $\mathbf{-3}$.
- In the Nitrate ion ($NO_3^-$), N is $\mathbf{+5}$.
They both converge to a single oxidation state of $\mathbf{+1}$ in $N_2O$.
Two states becoming one is Comproportionation (The exact reverse of Disproportionation).

7. Oxygen isn't always Negative!

Oxidation Rules

Scenario: What is the oxidation state of Oxygen in Oxygen Difluoride ($OF_2$) and Dioxygen Difluoride ($O_2F_2$)?

✖ What Students Do

Student rigidly adheres to the rule: "Oxygen is always -2 in its compounds."

They write -2 for Oxygen, forcing Fluorine into positive states to compensate.

(Fatal Error: Fluorine is the most electronegative element in the universe. It is NEVER positive!)

✔ The Correct Way

Fluorine forces Oxygen to be Positive!

Because Fluorine is more electronegative than Oxygen, F strictly takes the -1 state.

• In $\mathbf{OF_2}$: $x + 2(-1) = 0 \Rightarrow$ Oxygen is $\mathbf{+2}$.
• In $\mathbf{O_2F_2}$: $2x + 2(-1) = 0 \Rightarrow$ Oxygen is $\mathbf{+1}$.

(Also don't forget Peroxides where O is -1, and Superoxides where O is -1/2).

8. The "Fractional" Iron Trap

Mixed Oxides

Scenario: Determine the oxidation state of Iron (Fe) in Magnetite ($Fe_3O_4$).

✖ What Students Do

Student calculates it mathematically:

$$ 3x + 4(-2) = 0 \Rightarrow x = +8/3 $$

They submit +8/3 as the final answer, assuming it's a weird fractional quantum state.

✔ The Correct Way

Recognize it as a Mixed Oxide!

$Fe_3O_4$ is not a single compound with a uniform lattice. It is a stoichiometric mixture of two different iron oxides: $\mathbf{FeO \cdot Fe_2O_3}$.
Therefore, Iron exists in two distinct, integer oxidation states within the crystal:
- From $FeO$: Fe is $\mathbf{+2}$
- From $Fe_2O_3$: Fe is $\mathbf{+3}$
(+8/3 is merely the weighted average: $(1\times2 + 2\times3)/3 = 8/3$).

9. Double Oxidation n-Factor

Titration Calculations

Scenario: Calculate the n-factor of Ferrous Oxalate ($FeC_2O_4$) when it acts as a reducing agent against $KMnO_4$.

✖ What Students Do

Student sees Iron and immediately thinks: $Fe^{2+} \to Fe^{3+}$.

They conclude the change in electrons is 1, so $\mathbf{n\text{-factor} = 1}$.

(They completely ignored the other half of the molecule!)

✔ The Correct Way

BOTH the cation and anion get oxidized!

Ferrous Oxalate contains two reducing species:
1. Ferrous ion: $Fe^{2+} \to Fe^{3+} + 1e^-$ ($\mathbf{n=1}$)
2. Oxalate ion: $C_2O_4^{2-} \to 2CO_2 + 2e^-$ ($\mathbf{n=2}$)
Since both parts of the molecule lose electrons simultaneously, you add them together.
Total n-factor for $FeC_2O_4$ = $1 + 2 = \mathbf{3}$.

10. The Salt Bridge Illusion

Electrochemical Cells

Scenario: True or False: "The salt bridge completes the circuit by allowing electrons to flow from one half-cell to the other."

✖ What Students Do

Student knows a circuit must be a closed loop for electricity to flow.

They logically deduce that electrons travel through the wire, and return through the salt bridge. They answer True.

✔ The Correct Way

FALSE! Electrons NEVER enter the salt bridge!

Electrons strictly flow through the external metallic wire.
The salt bridge completes the inner circuit by allowing IONS to flow. Inert ions (like $K^+$ and $NO_3^-$) migrate into the half-cells to neutralize the charge buildup occurring at the electrodes, preventing the cell from stopping immediately.

11. Anode / Cathode Signs

Cell Fundamentals

Scenario: In a standard Galvanic (Voltaic) cell, what is the charge on the Anode?

✖ What Students Do

Student remembers Physics class or Electrolytic cells, where Anions (-) go to the Anode, meaning the Anode must be Positive (+).

They confidently answer Positive.

✔ The Correct Way

Remember the LOAN trick for Galvanic Cells!

In a Galvanic Cell (which produces electricity spontaneously):
Left side
Oxidation occurs here
Anode is its name
Negative is its charge

Because oxidation releases electrons at this electrode, it becomes electron-rich, hence Negative.

12. The Dichromate Balancing Error

Stoichiometry

Scenario: Balance the molecular equation using the oxidation number method. The dichromate ion $Cr_2O_7^{2-}$ acts as an oxidizer, becoming $Cr^{3+}$.

✖ What Students Do

Student calculates the oxidation state of Cr changes from +6 to +3.

They see a change of 3, and use '3' to cross-multiply with the reducing agent's change.

(The resulting balanced equation will be completely wrong!)

✔ The Correct Way

Multiply the change by the number of atoms!

Yes, one Chromium atom changes by 3 electrons ($+6 \to +3$).
HOWEVER, the Dichromate ion ($Cr_2O_7^{2-}$) contains TWO Chromium atoms.
The total change in oxidation number (total electrons transferred per molecule) is $3 \times 2 = \mathbf{6}$.
You must cross-multiply using 6!

13. The H2O2 Pigeonhole

Agents

Scenario: Hydrogen Peroxide ($H_2O_2$) reacts with Potassium Permanganate ($KMnO_4$) in acidic medium. Is $H_2O_2$ acting as an Oxidizing or Reducing agent?

✖ What Students Do

Student sees the word "Peroxide" and remembers it's used for bleaching and cleaning. They assume it is strictly an Oxidizing Agent.

✔ The Correct Way

Hydrogen Peroxide can do BOTH!

The oxidation state of Oxygen in $H_2O_2$ is -1. This is an intermediate state.
- It can decrease to -2 (in $H_2O$), acting as an Oxidizing Agent.
- It can increase to 0 (in $O_2$ gas), acting as a Reducing Agent.

Because $KMnO_4$ is an incredibly strong oxidizing agent, it forces $H_2O_2$ to act as a Reducing Agent, evolving $O_2$ gas!

14. Spontaneity & E-cell

Electrochemical Series

Scenario: You calculate $E^\circ_{cell} = -0.50V$ for a proposed redox reaction. Is the reaction feasible as written?

✖ What Students Do

Student remembers that Gibbs Free Energy ($\Delta G$) must be negative for a reaction to be spontaneous.

They see a negative sign on $E^\circ_{cell}$ and associate "negative" with "spontaneous". They answer Yes.

✔ The Correct Way

$E^\circ_{cell}$ MUST be Positive!

The relationship between Free Energy and Cell Potential is: $\Delta G^\circ = -nFE^\circ_{cell}$
Because of the built-in negative sign in the formula, for $\Delta G^\circ$ to be negative (spontaneous), the $E^\circ_{cell}$ value must be positive.
A negative $E^\circ_{cell}$ means the reaction is non-spontaneous (it will only proceed in the reverse direction).

15. Maximum Oxidation States

Periodic Trends

Scenario: What is the highest possible oxidation state exhibited by any element in the periodic table?

✖ What Students Do

Student remembers that Manganese ($Mn$) shows +7 in Permanganate ($MnO_4^-$), which is the highest they ever use in lab calculations.

Answer: +7.

✔ The Correct Way

The Maximum is +8!

While +7 is the max for the 3d transition series (Mn), elements heavier down the d-block can utilize all their valence s and d electrons.
Osmium (Os) and Ruthenium (Ru) (Group 8) can exhibit an oxidation state of $\mathbf{+8}$.
Example: Osmium Tetroxide ($OsO_4$), a highly toxic, volatile solid used in organic synthesis.

Confess Your Sins!

"Redox is all about fair exchange. Did you give the electrons what they deserved?"

Did one of these catch you? Or do you have a different horror story from your last exam?

Scroll down to the comments section below and tell us:

"Which redox trap were you falling for?"

↓

Quiz Revision Notes Downloads Class Notes Video Lectures